December 3, 2025

Black Maternal Mortality: A Crisis Rooted in History, Not Biology

Black Maternal Mortality: A Crisis Rooted in History, Not Biology

Black maternal mortality is often described as a “modern health crisis.” But to understand why the crisis exists, you have to look backward. The disparities we see today didn’t appear out of nowhere — they were shaped over centuries by unequal care, false medical beliefs, and systems that valued some families over others.

This isn’t about biology. It’s about history.

Black women have led families, built communities, delivered babies, and cared for others for generations. But the medical systems around them were often built without them — and too often, against them.

Understanding Black maternal mortality means understanding the long roots beneath it.

Where the Crisis Began

1. False medical beliefs created during slavery

Early physicians developed myths about Black women’s bodies — including the racist claim that they felt less pain. These ideas were never scientific, but they shaped treatment for centuries and still influence care today.

2. Enslaved women were denied consent, dignity, and safety

Medical experimentation, forced reproduction, poor birthing conditions, and forced labor during pregnancy left deep intergenerational consequences.

3. Midwifery suppression erased trusted community care

Black midwives — especially in the South — delivered babies safely for generations. When professional obstetrics pushed midwives out, many families lost skilled, trusted care.

4. Hospitals were built around segregation

Black families faced segregated wards, unequal resources, and dismissive treatment. These patterns shaped trust, access, and outcomes long before modern medicine existed.

5. Economic and social barriers restricted prenatal and postpartum care

From Jim Crow to redlining to employment discrimination, Black families often had less access to consistent medical support — not because of personal choices, but because of policy.

These aren’t old stories. They’re the roots of the present.

Where the Crisis Shows Up Today

Black women today are:

  • more likely to have their pain dismissed
  • more likely to have concerns ignored
  • more likely to face complications that go untreated
  • more likely to deliver in underfunded hospitals
  • less likely to receive continuity of care
  • more likely to experience implicit bias in medical settings

And Black women with college degrees still face higher maternal mortality rates than White women without a high school diploma — a statistic that makes the real cause impossible to deny.

This is not about income, education, or “risk factors.”
This is about systems.

Who Is Impacted?

Black women and Black birthing people

The core of the crisis — shaped by unequal care, implicit bias, and medical myths rooted in slavery.

Black families

Partners, children, and entire communities carry the emotional and economic impact of birth trauma and maternal loss.

Mixed-race families

Often navigate complex medical assumptions and biases during pregnancy and birth.

Rural communities of all races

Where many labor and delivery units have closed, worsening outcomes for Black families in those regions.

Immigrant Black communities

Face both racial bias and cultural or linguistic barriers to care.

This is a crisis with wider effects — but a crisis that lands hardest on Black women.

Why the Disparities Persist

1. Implicit bias in diagnosis and treatment

Black women’s symptoms are more likely to be minimized or misinterpreted.

2. Inconsistent postpartum follow-up

Complications like hemorrhage, infection, and hypertension often occur after the birth.

3. Unequal healthcare access

Hospital closures, transportation gaps, insurance barriers, and provider shortages affect many communities — but hit Black families hardest.

4. High-stress environments

Chronic stress from racism has measurable physical effects on pregnancy and birth outcomes.

5. Distrust rooted in real history

Generations of medical harm make trust difficult — and trust is essential to safe care.

This isn’t a mystery. The mechanisms are well-documented.
The problem is not that the causes are unknown — it’s that the causes are uncomfortable.

How This Crisis Affects Everyone

Maternal mortality is not just a “women’s issue.”

When mothers die, entire communities feel the impact:

  • children lose caregivers
  • families lose stability
  • workplaces lose leaders
  • communities lose teachers, aunties, mentors
  • health systems lose trust

The ripple effect reaches far beyond the hospital walls.

Signs of Change — and Where Hope Emerges

Despite the crisis, there are powerful movements pushing for better outcomes:

  • Black doulas and midwives rebuilding community birthwork
  • Legislation expanding postpartum Medicaid coverage
  • Implicit bias training for medical professionals
  • Doula reimbursement programs
  • Respected midwifery models returning in some states
  • Increased awareness and advocacy led by Black women themselves
  • Research centering Black maternal health as a core priority

These changes didn’t come from institutions alone — they came from the families and advocates who refused to let the crisis be ignored.

Why This History Matters

Because the data alone doesn’t tell the full story.

Understanding Black maternal mortality means understanding:

  • whose knowledge was dismissed
  • who was harmed in the development of obstetric medicine
  • how stereotypes shaped care
  • why some communities trust midwives over hospitals
  • why access isn’t equal even now
  • and why the solutions must center Black voices and Black expertise

This crisis wasn’t created by Black women — and it won’t be solved without honoring their experience and leadership.

Questions to Reflect On

  1. Whose voices shaped your own understanding of pregnancy and birth?
  2. How has medical trust — or distrust — been passed down in your community?
  3. What would safe, respectful, culturally grounded birth care look like today?

Dig Deeper: Accessible Sources

Black Mamas Matter Alliance
https://blackmamasmatter.org/

CDC — Maternal Mortality Statistics
https://cdc.gov/

NMAAHC — Medical Racism Collections
https://nmaahc.si.edu/

NIH — Reproductive Health Disparities
https://www.nih.gov/

National Birth Equity Collaborative
https://birthequity.org/